Innovation: The Lifeblood of

Chances are that a Procter & Gamble (P&G) product will cross the path of a consumer in the United States or any of 140 countries worldwide at least once throughout the course of an average day.  The Cincinnati, Ohio-based consumer and household products giant manufactures 300 brands, including Tide detergent, Crest toothpaste, Pampers diapers, Cover Girl cosmetics, and Pringles potato chips.  In order to stay at the forefront of the consumer products industry, "P&G is challenging managers in all categories to step up the innovation quotient" (Bittar, 2000).

The Procter & Gamble Company 

In 1837, candle maker William Procter joined forces with soap maker James Gamble to form The Procter & Gamble Company, known these days simply as "P&G."  Within 22 years, the company saw sales of $1 million, and its first brand—Ivory soap—was introduced 20 years later ("85 years," 1999).  Throughout its 163-year history, P&G has been known for its leadership in developing and marketing innovative brands and products to satisfy consumer needs. 

P&G saw a changing of the guard in early 1999, when president and chief operating officer Durk Jager succeeded John Pepper as president and chief executive of the company.  Pepper commented on Jager's ability to lead P&G into the future, saying that "he is an outstanding strategic thinker and a passionate advocate for greater innovation and speed" ("P&G Pursues Greatest Growth," 1998).  In September, Pepper relinquished his position as chairman of the board to Jager as well. 
 
 

P&G 1999 Sales By Category
CATEGORY 1999 SALES
(in millions)
MAJOR BRANDS
Laundry & Cleaning $11,517 Tide, Mr. Clean, Dawn
Paper $11,451 Puffs, Bounty, Charmin
Beauty Care $7,115 Cover Girl, Noxema
Food & Beverage
$4,381
Pringles, Folgers, Crisco
Health Care
$2,836
Nyquil, Vicks, Metamucil
TOTAL *
$38,125
*(w/adjustments)
Source: The Procter & Gamble Company, Hoover's Company Profile, 2000

Organization 2005 

Four years ago, in 1996, Procter & Gamble stated a lofty goal of doubling its $35 billion to $70 billion within in a decade ("The Procter & Gamble Company," 2000).  In order to achieve this sales goal, the company must realize consistent annual growth rates of roughly 7 percent.  "We know the key is faster, bigger innovation in every part of our business," says Jager (Tomkins, 1998).  His strategy: a massive reorganization of P&G's operations called Organization 2005, hitting everything from restructuring for increased globalization to changing the corporate culture of the old economy company. 

Until the beginning of the restructuring program, P&G divided its operations into four geographical regions: North America; Europe, Middle East, and Africa; Asia; and Latin America.  Under Organization 2005, the company has re-divided its business to shift responsibility for making profits to brands, rather than geographic regions.  A focus of the restructuring program is to design new product introductions for global reach, rather than simply sticking to one region. 

The program consists of five major transitions: 

  • Global Business Units (GBU): seven business units based on product lines (Baby Care, Beauty Care, Fabric & Home Care, Feminine Protection, Food & Beverage, Health Care & Corporate, Tissues & Towel) 
  • Market Development Organizations (MDO): eight organizations to develop tailored programs and strategies for P&G's global business (North America, Central & Eastern Europe, Middle East/Africa/General Export, Western Europe, ASEAN/India/Australasia, Japan/Korea, Greater China, Latin America) 
  • Global Business Services (GBS): provide business services including accounting, human resources systems, order management, and information technology to the Global Business Units 
  • Corporate Functions:  P&G corporate staff moved to business units, some remain to focus on knowledge and corporate functions 
  • Culture: bolder environment with "more stretching goals and plans, bigger innovations, and greater speed" to market 

  • ("Organization 2005," 1999)


Research & Development 

In a strategic sense, innovation comes from a company's dedication to research and development of new products and "pioneers," or products and businesses that represent new growth and value potential for the company's portfolio (Kim & Mauborgne, 1998).  Procter & Gamble is a leader in R&D investments, with $1.5 billion spent in 1998.  The company, which holds nearly 25,000 patents and adds to that total each year, announced that "it is prepared  to give away or license any of its 25,000 patents, including those used in established brands" ("Business: Jager's Gamble," 1999). Recently, P&G donated 100 patents to Western Michigan University's Paper Technology Foundation, Inc., citing that the company has "more innovative technologies than [it] can develop" ("P&G Donates Rights," 2000).

P&G's capacity for research and development is impressive: 7,500 scientists, including1,250 Ph.D.s, working in 22 world-class research facilities across the globe ("Product Innovation," 1999).  The company prides itself on its ability to apply knowledge about consumers and technologies across product categories.  For example, the merging of P&G knowledge from various product areas was evident in a recent market test of Olay Daily Facials, the new facial cleansing and moisturizing cloth from the Oil of Olay brand. Daily Facials brought research from paper, laundry, beauty care, and even the food division of P&G, using information from the development of the Olestra fat substitute for the cloth's moisturizer (Nelson, 2000).

Industry analysts and executives within P&G cite moving beyond incremental improvements to existing brands and developing truly innovative new brands as one of the issues the company must address in the future.  This may serve as a problem for P&G's top managers, who "are trained to squeeze the last drop of sales out of existing products, not back risky new ones" ("Business: Jager's Gamble," 1999).  CEO Durk Jager has his work cut out for him in changing the conservative P&G culture to allow for out-of-the-box (or in this case, brand) thinking.  Jager conceded that the company's last major category invention happened in the 1980's, and that since then, true innovation came second to taking core brands into global markets (Edgecliffe-Johnson, 1999).

P&G's History of 'Firsts'

Year 
Product
1948 Tide: first synthetic detergent
1962 Crest: first fluoride toothpaste 
1972 Pampers: first disposable diaper
1975 Bounce: first fabric softener dryer sheet
1988  Pert Plus: first 2-in-1 shampoo and conditioner
Source: "85 Years," 1999, "Living In Future," 1999

P&G's focus with Organization 2005 is to get "more innovations in the pipeline than ever before" (Bittar, 2000) and take them to consumers with greater speed and wider global reach.  The program may prove successful, if recent product introductions are any indication.  Four of P&G's latest product developments have used P&G's research expertise to satisfy new consumer needs in the fabric care, cleaning, and food areas. 

  • Dryel fabric care system allows home cleaning of dry-clean-only clothing. The Dryel system uses pre-moistened cloths with odor-removing vapors to penetrate the fabric without fading or shrinking dry-clean-only clothing. The Dryel kit includes a stain remover and absorbent cloths, pre-moistened Dryel cloths, and a reusable Dryel bag. 
  • Febreze fabric spray removes odors from lightweight and heavy fabrics and upholstery. As the formula dries into the fabric, odors are cleaned away, leaving clothing, drapes, and other fabrics smelling fresh. In summer 2000, P&G will introduce Febreze Clean Wash, a liquid laundry aid for use with regular detergent. 
  • Swiffer cleaning cloths use an electrostatic charge to attract and trap household dirt and dust. The cloths can be used by hand as disposable dust cloths, or they can be attached to the lightweight Swiffer sweeper for use on floors and other surfaces. 
  • Fit Fruit & Vegetable Wash removes dirt, pesticides, and handling residue from produce, making it safer and healthier to eat. It is available in spray, soak, and rinse form, as well as in a heavy-duty commercial form under the name Professional Line Fit Antibacterial Produce Cleaner. 
Uncertain Future

Making a calculated effort toward innovation and globalization may prove to be quite a task, even for the likes of Procter & Gamble.  After announcing in March that earnings growth would fall short of the 6-8 percent required to double sales to $70 billion by 2005, the company saw its stock plummet 31 percent in one day.  Will Durk Jager be able to recapture industry confidence through the bold move toward innovative new products and categories and greater speed in taking those products to global markets?  With that left to be seen, P&G's future will prove very interesting. 
 

Additional Sites

P&G Investor Info

P&G Newsroom

Hoover's Company Capsule - Procter & Gamble

Fortune's Global 500 

Yahoo
 

Review Questions

  1. How is P&G redefining its operating structure through the Organization 2005 program?
  2. What is the main issue surrounding incremental innovation at P&G?
  3. How does CEO Durk Jager expect the program to help P&G meet its goal of doubling sales to $70 billion by 2005?
References
  1. 85 years of vision, innovation and commitment. (1999, December). Canadian Business and Current Affairs, 113(12), p. 1-22. 
  2. Bittar, C. (2000, March 20). P&G's monumental repackaging project. Brandweek, 41(12), p. 40-52.
  3. Business: Jager's gamble. (1999, October 30). The Economist (London), 353(8143), p. 75.
  4. Edgecliffe-Johnson, A. (1999, June 10). P&G cuts 15,000 jobs in attempt to pep up sales. Financial Times (London), p. 1.
  5. History of innovation. (no date). Procter & Gamble Investor Information. [Online]. Available: http://www.pg.com/investor/innov/history.html [2000, May 23].
  6. Kim, W. C. & Mauborgne, R. (1998, August 11). Pioneers strike it rich: Management strategy. Financial Times (London), p. 11.
  7. 'Living in future' is just one of the secrets behind new product breakthroughs at Procter & Gamble. (1999, May 18). Canada NewsWire - Lexis Nexis. [Online: 977 words]. Available: http://web.lexis-nexis.com [2000, May 23].
  8. Marshall, A. (1999, May 26). Corporate profile: Procter takes a gamble to go truly global.  The Independent (London), p. 3.
  9. Nelson, E. (2000, May 16). Procter & Gamble tries to hide wrinkles in aging beauty fluid. The Wall Street Journal Interactive Edition. [Online]. Available: http://interactive.wsj.com [2000, May 16].
  10. Organization 2005 program overview. 1999, June 9). P&G News Releases. [Online]. Available: http://www.pg.com/about/news/news.shtml [2000, April 6]. 
  11. Product innovation at P&G. (1999, June 9). P&G News Releases. [Online]. Available: http://www.pg.com/about/news/news.shtml [2000, May 23]. 
  12. P&G donates rights to more than 100 pending patents for commercial development. (2000, March 30). PR Newswire - Lexis Nexis. [Online: 1174 words]. Available: http://web.lexis-nexis.com [2000, May 23].
  13. P&G pursues greatest growth ever. (1998, September 9). PR Newswire - Lexis Nexis. [Online: 2150 words]. Available: http://web.lexis-nexis.com [2000, May 23].
  14. The Procter & Gamble Company. (2000). Hoover's Company Profile - Lexis Nexis. [Online: 1811 words]. Available: http://web.lexis-nexis.com [2000, May 23].
  15. Tomkins, R. (1998, September 3). The what, not the where, to drive P&G. Financial Times (London), p. 34.